BLOG

The Summer I Turned Media Literate

As media evolves and grows, embedding itself into every aspect of life, along with it, its rulebook morphs and takes a turn for the worse. What was once considered wildly unethical is suddenly the norm. Let me elaborate: Although, as an audience, we’re far more aware and hold bad mouthing accountable to the highest degree through “cancel culture”, simultaneously, we turn more of a blind eye towards the oligarchical media moguls and their new, flashy extraction methods. From their sly and sneaky advertising to their AI-ification of EVERYTHING possible, our lack of resistance is only making them more daring. Let’s get into it, divas! 

On a lighter note, have you heard of the show that has completely hijacked the internet? Of course, I’m talking about what EVERYone’s talking about, “The Summer I Turned Pretty”. A beachside teen romance with the most heart-wrenching love triangle of all time (yes, it trumps The Vampire Diaries Boo Hoo). This summer, their third and last season aired through a weekly release format and every Wednesday, it absolutely captivated the internet. Harboring over 25 million viewers globally on Prime Video and 13.8 billion views on TikTok under #TheSummerITurnedPretty, it made a very tasty feast for everyone to take a bite out off and capitalise. And by “everyone”, I mean within the media ecosystem, from micro-influencers, big brands, the audience and obviously, the direct production. 

Generally, I pride myself on my investigative ability to discern advertising from content, and though calling this an “ investigation” may sound dramatic, as time goes by, it truly feels like one: Whether its figuring out if a video is Ai or not, or if a micro influencer is getting paid to promote a product, the lines are getting exceedingly blurry. Which comes back to my point, this show, like other contemporary cultural phenomena, is utilised opportunistically in social media. Like a race, influencers and marketers wait at the starting line, and whoever posts related content first, wins with the most views. Additionally, the shows exclusivity drives the audience towards seeking additional interaction through varying avenues, from fandom culture to even hyper analysis into implicit discovery.

With this fame, its common for show’s to parade around a multitude of brand deals: There were the explicitly promoted brand deals such as Coach, American Eagle and Steve Madden. But, through further analysis, there seems to be some hidden underneath. 

In the show, the main character is proposed to by one party of this intense love triangle (Jeremiah) with a noticeably skinny, frail ring, which sparked a chain reaction of events. First, it began with mockery of the ring, turning it into a running joke, and then this brewed into curiosity, which fueled the micro influencers who jumped in to discover the origin of the ring. Now, the star of our show comes into play: Catbird, aka creator of said tin foil ring. Only after the audience completed the circle from mockery -> curiosity -> investigation -> discovery, the collaboration of Catbird X The summer I Turned Pretty collection was announced and released.

Mockery -> Curiosity -> Investigation -> Discovery

Though not formally theorised, this orchestration can be categorised as “delayed signifiers” which are when details, symbols or narrative element’s complete meaning is intentionally revealed later. Catbird not only carefully engineered the discovery, it could also be deduced that they’re capitalising off the emotion elicited by the viewers, and to put it simply, outsourcing the marketing and reaping its benefit.  This is a snippet of the plight of our future advertising, as Hardy says, “traditional branded media is in the past”, and the future of advertising now is all a guessing game. 

  

Oh no, another Bollywood Breach!

My dear readers, I have a confession to make! Though I’ve lived all my life in India, watched my fair share of atrocious Bollywood films, and participated in cringy meme generation of said films, I have never devoted time towards truly deconstructing and analysing the media industries in my country.  And to make matters worse, yes, I indeed am a full-time media student…I’m not entirely sure if this lack of analysis comes from simple callousness or a subconscious fear of the answers I may find. Maybe it’s something even deeper. (which I will definitely be unpacking with my therapist)  

(Translation: Bollywood Queen)

Let’s play a game of visualisation! Close your eyes for a second and imagine this, you’re suddenly in India, sitting on your couch. You either switch on the television or unlock your phone and open a news channel or an app, maybe NDTV India, Zee News or even Aaj Tak, and suddenly, there it is: this week’s controversy flashing in front of you.

“India’s Got Latent”

This time, it happens to be the Latent show controversy: A popular comedy show on YouTube invited a few well-known internet personalities as guests, and since it is a comedy show, a couple of inappropriate jokes were made. Were they in bad taste? Yes. But what you’re now seeing on the news is something far bigger. These guests are now being condemned for “disrespecting Indian values”, and court cases and death threats are being hurled at them, all over a comedy show. Your mind is bubbling with questions now. How and why did this become a national scandal, when there are far more important issues, such as the farmers’ crisis and ongoing water conflicts, that would truly benefit from this coverage? 

Now open your eyes.. And let’s get to digging! 

Here is where our trusty economists and scholars come in handy! Though Marx never explicitly theorized media, his conclusive stance on how fundamental institutions act as vehicles of capitalism helps us continue our delve into mass media and how it upholds India’s capitalist economy. Indian media almost feels like a battlefield of various ideologies, but in actuality, the true control lies in the hands of a select few at the top. They use entertainment and drama as a tool to distract the general public from “class consciousness” and their favourite topic of distraction is…. You guessed it, Bollywood! From Bollywood star Alia Bhatt’s nepotism to Ranveer Singh’s affair, the media covers ALL except for an alarming economic crisis that’s actually affecting the country. With overwhelming diversions, they successfully distract the audience from critically engaging with news and finding fault with capitalism. And if the distractions don’t work, say hello to Mass media’s alter ego: manipulation! (Just like my ex). Indian media spreads dangerous ideas like the notion of meritocracy, which manipulates the general public into thinking that socioeconomic inequalities are based on merit instead of social background. The Media’s coverage is thus biased with stories of “successes despite caste or poverty”, manipulating us into believing that capitalism actually allows class mobility. Media’s capitalism, to some extent, has even succeeded in dominating our media with religious bigotry and capitalist convention, but I believe there’s still hope. 

 As media’s presence grows, people seem to be evolving and learning along. For starters, let’s look at Youth ki Awaaz(Voice of Youth), India’s largest citizens media platform. Here, the youth take up the opportunity to write about any issue they’d like to bring attention to, with no restrictions. With over 200,000 writers, (including me), platforms like these give us the media that we deserve. The kind that informs and entertains with no filter or ulterior motive, making traditional media more accessible to the laymen and giving us the power to influence. 

Ni Lo Digo, Duolingo! 

Source: Pinterest

A mere thirty days into my Duolingo journey of learning Spanish, I was hit with some devastating news: The company was transforming to a complete AI-based foundation. Recently, I’ve been struggling to hide from this heavy integration into every aspect of our beings. Don’t get me wrong, I understand how AI could feel like a golden ticket to companies: allowing them to cut costs and even then, get rewarded with efficiency and growth like no other. However, for those of us trying to navigate an already fast-paced life, this shift intensifies a different craving. A craving for human involvement. Growing up learning from teachers in classrooms or even through YouTube videos and live streams had a certain charm and warmth to it. Studies consistently show that students report higher trust and long-term motivation when guided by human instructors than by automated systems.  

This is why, apart from the AI switch, I realised, if Duolingo transitioned into a paid platform, I wouldn’t subscribe. I’d rather put my money towards a Spanish teacher, whose labour, teaching expertise and emotional investment I’d value. Drawing on Smythe, my money should circle back into human labour and not disappear into the money pile of multi-billion-dollar corporations whose gamification, proven in cases, decreases learning efficiency.  So, naturally, I bid adieu to the cheeky little green bird and along with it my thirty-day streak of Spanish learning, Ni Lo Digo, Duolingo (translation: No way, Duo Lingo). 

Comment your size and I will send you a free anti Duolingo merchandise!

As for addictive applications like TikTok and Instagram, I’ve come to realize that despite us devoting such large periods of time towards using them, a large percentage of their users seem to be apprehensive when questioned on whether the application truly makes them happy. Though initially, social media was just a profitable business opportunity eagerly taken up by tech companies, its true purpose was to embed a social element to the digital space. But, as it’s grown and transformed, it feels as if it has only amplified isolation and pulled us further away from humanity. Like Pandora’s box, Instagram seems to affect its users with the same hypnotic pull towards opening the app, like the box, and when we do, we’re rushing towards shutting it down, frightened by the damaging effects of its content on us and our mental health. Though, instead of mythical forces, Instagram is equipped with the endless scroll mechanism designed in every platform to keep us hooked, surveillance capitalism and ironclad algorithmic accuracy, making it almost impossible for audiences to resist this pretty trap.  

Guys, I think Smythe was talking about us : ( To put it simply, if Instagram were a paid platform or not, either way, by using their application, we inherently pay up either through cash or kind. “Kind” being through our free labour, attention and the joy of being yet another unit in their machine. (I hope you can sense my sarcasm)

Your payment idea is not just about labour but about ethical redistribution, power, ownership, and social good.

Murdock & Golding (1973)

When the question of payment is discussed, it’s to be immediately followed up with the question of power. Who holds the power and benefit, and most importantly, whose work am I reinforcing? It’s about time we put effort into consuming media more intentionally, as this harbours strong social good. Together, through supporting human workers and protecting creativity, we can push back against extractive and surveillance-based media systems. 

I’d like to conclude with a special message for Peter Golding: 

*Clears throat* 

Ma man Mr. Golding, one of these days, If you’re ever down to help fix capitalism with me, please (with a cherry on top) give me a call! Thanks.. 

Chicken Soup at £5.99? Nope, more like 3 ml ²/hr 

Eureka, I’ve got it! I can proudly state that I have officially coined the unit of measurement to help you appropriately track how much mental labour you’re clocking in daily, it’s “ml ²/hr” (mental labour ²/hr)! It’s still a work in progress, but I assure you I’m inching closer towards success. Then again, math and physics were never my strong suits, so don’t take my word for it just yet!  

As we naturally gravitate towards the treacherous, final stretch of the year, Flu season officially commences along with it. Unfortunately for me, I am a recurring prey to this season, all thanks to my pitiful immune system. This year, I’m officially putting on my big girl pants and joining the “preventative measures” club, which brings me to my point. I am a firm believer that nothing quite warms you up like a good ol’ bowl of hot chicken soup. I recently came across a delightful recipe from an Instagram creator whose videos frequently appear on my feed, but I forgot to save it on my account. So, I searched them up and began scrolling through their feed. On and on, I went until, after what felt like an eternity, I finally came across the desired video. This strenuous exercise of the “scroll” got me thinking about this free labour that each one of us clocks in daily. Drawing from Terranova, this concept of free labour refers to the unpaid, voluntary and often pleasurable work we, social media frequenters, perform daily that is extracted as data and monetised by money-hungry corporations. So, I took on the challenge of identifying the most efficient route to a chicken soup recipe with the least amount of digital extraction for me to stomach (and I’m not talking about the soup). 

Pictorial representation of my internal battle

On assembling all the social media avengers, I narrowed down my options. Instagram/TikTok, YouTube or Google. I think it’s safe to say that the journey down Instagram is a dead end due to the endless scroll mechanism, along with advertising peeking out from every possible corner. Moving on to Google, which involves interacting with a search engine that immediately begins tracking and building a detailed profile of my interests and behaviorial patterns through small data files, deceitfully known as “cookies”. They extract your personal data and utlise it to serve you highly targeted ads across Google and partnered websites. On YouTube, the most labour I’d be performing is the time spent watching the video of the recipe, each second is transformed into value. Additionally, any interaction through liking or subscribing contributes to the video’s visibility, translating into profit. Not only are my preferences recorded and extracted, I failed to take into account the worst of all: The unskippable ads that have undoubtedly shed years off my life. Ugh, perhaps I could purchase a cookbook?

 Despite the assumption that I have a plethora of avenues through social media to procure exactly what i need; free of cost, through deconstruction, we realise the contradictory, dynamic nature of these platforms. Instead, I choose to take on another perspective of Sricek’s; The deeper contradiction encompassing intimacy and care.  Though platforms continue to give their best go at commodifying all of human demensions, I believe they’re still pretty far off. Put simply, the chicken soup I finally prepared was absolutely scrumptious, best believe, it got all the rave from my flatmates. They said it made them feel comforted and happy, feelings elicited solely towards my chicken soup and the love I put into it. Hopefully I remember the recipe for next time, I can’t waste another 3 ml ²/hr next week!   

Flo or flop?

I’d like to begin with a question for my readers: Do you have an app you use that genuinely brings you comfort? The kind that you open and instantly feel calmer, safer, or even one that makes you feel like you truly belong. Let me know! 

Personally, for me it was an application called “Flo health”. Typically, between the ages 10-15 it’s common for a girl to start menstruating, commencing an extremely daunting period (no pun intended) of life. Suddenly, there’s a different dimension to living and you have to navigate through it all with the added bonus of inexplainable hormonal changes that make you want to scream, cry or both all at once. Unlike a regular period tracker, the app Flo comes built in with features covering all bases of overwhelm. It has an insights section that provides 101’s and simple tests to answer questions ranging from reproductive health, sex, birth control to even PMS and OB-GYN recommendations. The app also has a built-in chat space with sub-chat rooms designed for the users to participate in anonymous conversations for reassurance, advice and unfiltered chats. Additionally, they also provide “Flo partner” a feature enabling your partner to have access to your cycle tracker on their phone, with advice and tutorials to aid their navigation of the cycle and all it encompasses beyond just menstruation. All in all, the app aims to tackle every avenue holistically, and emulate feelings of care, comfort and convenience towards their users. They play a role in recognition of our constant maintenance towards ourselves and our bodies. Feminist economists like Nancy Folbre and Silvia Fedirici have for decades talked about reproductive labour and how it feels like Harry Potter’s invisibility cloak is their everyday attire. Flo’s interface works so well because it conveniently positions itself within the illusion that every feature and component takes into consideration how their users feel, rather than just ticking a box, which touches upon another aspect of recognising their emotional labour. Flo’s marketing, positions the app as an alternative to traditional healthcare and strategically resonates within the illusion that its purpose is devoted towards women empowerment. From their slogans, to their girlboss hashtags, it all leans into the idea of feminism to enhance appeal towards women. 

Flo’s interface

The global Femtech industry is currently estimated at 68 billion USD and projected to reach 117 billion USD by 2029. Where is all this money coming from, you ask? The unfortunate answer to this question: “Flo Health class action lawsuit”. Turns out they’ve been sharing intimate health data such as menstrual cycle length, ovulation patterns and hormonal data with Meta, Flurry and Google etc, without user consent; Absolutely devastating their users. This proves that femtech operates as a data driven industry, extracting data from the users and transforming into profitable predictions and marketing material. Beyond the giftwrap of women’s empowerment and feminist illusion, underneath, it also perpetuates neoliberal subjugation of burdening the user with the pressure of maintaining their “health” through self-tracking. Simultaneously, they reiterate this within heteronormative boundaries of femininity.  

Source: Pinterest

The toxicity of femtech runs deeper given the current political climate; With the overturning of Roe v. Wade heavily contributed to creating an unsafe space for women, not only does data get extracted for marketing, there’s also the fear that it could be used as evidence in legal proceedings; Users search history or missed period could expose them to the risk of criminal prosecution. As we’re subjected to greater fear and greater extraction, the industries only seem to be turning in higher profits and higher gains, continuing this devastating cycle.